Binding corporate rules (BCR)
Binding corporate rules (BCR) are data protection rules that a group of companies follows when it transfers personal data to group companies in countries outside the EU/EEA. BCR are a basis for transfers under GDPR Article 46(2)(b) and Article 47 and must be approved by the competent supervisory authority after the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) has issued an opinion.
Back to Dictionary- Dictionary
- Binding corporate rules (BCR)
Table of Contents
Groups with companies outside the EU/EEA often move personal data between them every day, for HR, IT support or customer service. Each of those transfers needs a basis under Chapter V of the GDPR, and binding corporate rules are one designed for transfers within a group. Our GDPR compliance guide puts transfers in the context of the other requirements.
Who binding corporate rules are for
Article 4(20) of the GDPR defines BCR as personal data protection policies that a controller or processor established in a Member State adheres to for transfers of personal data to a controller or processor in one or more third countries "within a group of undertakings, or group of enterprises engaged in a joint economic activity" (Regulation (EU) 2016/679).
BCR are one of the ways to meet the rules on third-country transfer. They only cover transfers inside the group. A transfer to an external recipient, such as a supplier outside the group, needs another basis, for example standard contractual clauses. Our third-country transfers guide goes through the options.
What the rules must contain
Under Article 47(1), the competent supervisory authority approves BCR in accordance with the consistency mechanism in Article 63, provided that they:
- are legally binding and apply to and are enforced by every member of the group concerned, including their employees
- expressly confer enforceable rights on data subjects with regard to the processing of their personal data
- fulfil the requirements in Article 47(2)
Article 47(2) sets out the minimum content. Among other things, the rules must specify:
- the structure and contact details of the group
- the data transfers and the third countries concerned
- their legally binding nature
- the application of the general data protection principles
- the rights of data subjects and the means to exercise them
- that a member established in the EU accepts liability for breaches by members established outside the EU
The article lists further items, including how complaints are handled.
How BCR are approved
The competent supervisory authority approves BCR under the consistency mechanism. Before it does, the EDPB issues an opinion, as Article 64(1)(f) requires whenever a supervisory authority intends to approve BCR. Once approved, BCR provide appropriate safeguards for transfers without requiring any specific authorisation from a supervisory authority (Article 46(2)(b)).
The EDPB has published Recommendations 1/2022 on the application for approval and on the elements and principles to be found in controller BCR. The final version is dated 20 June 2023.
BCR, standard contractual clauses and adequacy
| BCR | Standard contractual clauses | Adequacy decision | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who uses it | A group of undertakings or of enterprises engaged in a joint economic activity | Exporter and importer, also between unrelated companies | Anyone transferring to the country, territory or sector covered |
| Approval | Competent supervisory authority after an EDPB opinion | Clauses adopted by the European Commission, signed as a contract | Decision by the European Commission |
| Typical use | Recurring transfers within a group | Transfers to suppliers and other external recipients | Transfers to a country the Commission has found adequate |
For the United States, the EU-US Data Privacy Framework is an adequacy decision that covers certified companies. Infringements of the rules on transfers to third countries (Articles 44 to 49) can lead to fines of up to EUR 20 million or 4% of total worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher (Article 83(5)(c)).
Transfer bases in .legal
In .legal, you set the specific transfer basis in the third-country settings on the legal entity, and the extended record of processing activities shows recipients in the EU, in safe third countries and in unsafe third countries, together with the transfer basis. Whether a transfer is lawful, and whether BCR suit your group, is not something the platform decides.
Frequently asked questions about binding corporate rules
Who can use binding corporate rules?
A group of undertakings, or a group of enterprises engaged in a joint economic activity, can use BCR for transfers of personal data from members in the EU/EEA to members in third countries. The rules must be legally binding on every member concerned, including employees, and must be approved by the competent supervisory authority.
Who approves BCR in Denmark?
BCR are approved by the competent supervisory authority under the consistency mechanism in Article 63 of the GDPR. In Denmark the supervisory authority is Datatilsynet, the Danish Data Protection Agency. Before an authority approves BCR, the European Data Protection Board issues an opinion under Article 64(1)(f).
What is the difference between BCR and standard contractual clauses?
BCR are a group's own rules, approved by a supervisory authority after an EDPB opinion, and they cover transfers within the group. Standard contractual clauses are adopted by the European Commission and signed as a contract between exporter and importer, also between unrelated companies. Both are appropriate safeguards under Article 46(2).
Can BCR be used for transfers to suppliers outside the group?
No. Article 4(20) limits BCR to transfers within a group of undertakings or a group of enterprises engaged in a joint economic activity. A transfer to an external supplier in a third country needs another basis, for example standard contractual clauses or an adequacy decision.
What must binding corporate rules contain at a minimum?
Article 47(2) sets the minimum content. It includes the group's structure and contact details, the transfers and third countries concerned, the legally binding nature of the rules, the application of the general data protection principles, the rights of data subjects and how to exercise them, and the liability of an EU member for breaches by members outside the EU.